‘Star Trek: Unusual New Worlds’ probes the boundaries of redemption

The next comprises spoilers for “Beneath the Cloak of Struggle.”

“Some issues break in a manner that may by no means be repaired, solely managed.” It’s the ultimate line in a powerhouse episode of Star Trek: Unusual New Worlds. “Beneath the Cloak of Struggle” lays out a bunch of questions on reminiscence, grief and redemption – reiterating the important thing obsessions of this season – none of which it might probably reply. For some reveals, this may be a foul factor, however Unusual New Worlds is turning into more and more comfy dwelling with ambiguity. A lot as I could also be flush with recency bias, I already really feel it could be the standout of the season.

The Enterprise has been requested to hold Dak’Rah (An unrecognizable Robert Knowledge), a profitable, however deeply controversial, Federation ambassador to the Prospero system. Controversial as a result of he’s a Klingon who defected throughout the current warfare, who’s often known as the “Butcher of J’Gal.” Not simply due to the orders he gave, together with massacring his personal civilians, however as a result of he killed all of his generals simply earlier than he defected. Dak’Rah is embraced by Pike, Una and Uhura as a beacon of hope for a extra peaceable future. However Ortegas, who fought within the warfare, and M’Benga and Chapel, who truly served in a discipline hospital on J’Gal, can’t recover from the previous, or their very own ache. 

We flash again to Chapel’s arrival on J’Gal, the place she’s greeted by Trek good luck allure Clint Howard’s commanding officer. Her orientation lasts for all of a minute earlier than she’s selecting up casualties from the transporter pad and attempting to save lots of them with out key medical tech. One soldier will get loaded into the sample buffer to maintain him alive till rescue arrives, whereas others get operated on the old school manner. M’Benga and Chapel shortly bond over their tough time within the medical trenches, and develop a shorthand to assist one another alongside.


Within the current, Pike asks all three to quell their objections and are available to dinner with Dak’Rah, who’s attempting to carry courtroom over the captain’s desk. None of them are capable of make good for too lengthy, and Ortegas shortly leaves, with Chapel following behind. Pike notices that whereas M’Benga stays, he’s gripping the arms of his seat so tightly that he’s about to tear them off, and asks him to go take care of the absent pair. However not earlier than Ra, realizing that M’Benga loves martial arts, asks to arrange a session between the 2 with an arm grip that’s slightly too aggressive.

Again on J’Gal, M’Benga treats a wounded soldier who wonders what the purpose of this battle actually is. The physician provides a rousing speech, bringing to thoughts the “you need me on that wall” speech from Aaron Sorkin’s A Few Good Males. He says the danger of Klingon expansionism is simply too nice, and that Starfleet fights in order that others can reside their lives in peace. However whereas the speech is efficient, it’s delivered slightly too convincingly, particularly given we quickly be taught that M’Benga was the man wielding the knife moderately than the scalpel.

Quickly after, a particular forces commander asks M’Benga for some Protocol 12, the inexperienced steroids M’Benga and Chapel utilized in “The Damaged Circle.” As aggravated as I used to be that M’Benga himself created it – I’m by no means a fan of secret origin tales the place the identical 5 characters are on the heart of actually the whole lot within the universe – I used to be happy we didn’t get an over-explanation of its genesis. The physician refuses, so the commander asks if M’Benga himself, underneath his outdated guise of “The Ghost” will be part of the group on its daring mission given how efficient his homicide expertise are, or have been.

The army is planning to ship a small unit to attempt to wipe out J’Gal’s leaders as soon as and for all, whereas committing the majority of its forces to a grand frontal assault as a distraction. The soldier M’Benga beforehand patched up goes again on the market to get chopped up, everybody realizing forward of time they’re being despatched to the meat grinder. However the Klingons are prepared for them, disabling the sphere hospital’s energy turbines, stopping them from saving the casualties as they pile up. Chapel will get a transporter on-line, however can’t activate it with out wiping the soldier who was stored within the sample buffer earlier, one thing M’Benga does with little hesitation.

Again on the ship, M’Benga and Dak’Rah begin their sparring session, with Dak’Rah doing his greatest to attempt to make good with the physician. He talks about how good the symbolism of two former enemies, fairly actually on the other sides of the identical battle, standing side-by-side could be. However M’Benga can’t convey himself to be associates, simply allies, and shortly begins to ask Dak’Rah which of his generals fought the toughest throughout his remaining day on J’Gal. Dak’Rah can’t reply, as a result of it wasn’t Dak’Rah that killed them, however M’Benga, hopped up on his personal fury steroids and searching for revenge.

The Enterprise takes a shortcut to get their undesirable Klingon off the ship earlier than somebody will get damage, however not earlier than Dak’Rah as soon as once more goes to M’Benga. The Physician is taking a look at his little private results case, which features a D’k tahg he stored as a reminder from J’Gal. They talk about the fallout from their prior dialogue, with M’Benga offended that Dak’Rah has used the deaths M’Benga brought on to launder his personal status. We minimize, then, to the opposite aspect of the physician’s workplace, by way of partially-opaque glass, because the pair scuffle, earlier than chopping again to Dak’Rahdead on the ground with a dagger in his chest.

Chapel supplies cowl for M’Benga, saying Dak’Rah brought on the battle, which M’Benga agrees to, regardless of Pike urgent him for an off-the-record request for forgiveness. He tells his captain he’s not accountable, however he’s glad his outdated enemy is he stored as a reminder from J’Gal. They talk about the fallout from their prior dialogue, with M’Benga offended that Dak’Rah has used the deaths M’Benga brought on to launder his personal status. We minimize, then, to the opposite aspect of the physician’s workplace, by way of partially-opaque glass, because the pair scuffle, earlier than chopping again to Dak’Rah useless on the ground with a dagger in his chest.

L-R Babs Olusanmokun as Dr. M'Benga and Anson Mount as Capt. Pike in Star Trek: Strange New Worlds streaming on Paramount+, 2023. Photo Credit: Michael Gibson/Paramount+

Michael Gibson/Paramount+

If there’s one factor that Star Trek (each again within the day and now) can generally overlook, it’s that historical past doesn’t simply occur to different folks. As a lot because it focuses on the good folks of historical past making soliloquies on the bridge of their starships, that’s the beginning of issues, not the tip. Regardless of its obvious progressivism, it hardly ever engages with the fabric issues of the peculiar folks dwelling and serving in Starfleet on that form of degree. That’s why the very fact we obtained to see the Klingon warfare from one thing approaching the bottom is a refreshing change.

And at the beginning of the season, I talked about how assured Unusual New Worlds’ storytelling had change into. Bursting out of the gate, even its weaker episodes have been elevated by a manufacturing group pulling their hardest in the identical course. With a powerful script, credited to author/producer Davy Perez and directed by Jeff W. Boyd, there’s not a lot that may go mistaken. It helps, too, that Unusual New Worlds this 12 months has restrained its urge to clarify, and over-explain, each side of what’s occurring. However what actually makes this episode is the towering, blockbuster efficiency by Babs Olusanmokun as Dr. M’Benga who, as soon as once more, demonstrates he’s this collection secret weapon.

It’s Olusanmokun who holds the broad tangle of concepts on this script collectively, together with the important thing points round reminiscence, grief and forgiveness. There’s a transparent dichotomy between these within the crew who’re motivated for revenge and people who are wanting towards a greater future. I’m certain that individual battle might be mapped over a number of real-world fault traces, for higher or worse. The episode, correctly, doesn’t essentially take one aspect over the opposite, though the very fact M’Benga and Chapel are our POV characters this week means we’re already on aspect.

It’s a disgrace that there’s much less emphasis on making Dak’Rah as totally rounded-out a personality as he might, or needs to be. He’s not given area to justify Pike’s religion in him, and it’s clear just about as quickly as he arrives that he’s ever so barely phony. A lot of this may be attributed to our outdated enemy working time, and the truth that Unusual New Worlds’ storytelling is that rather more bold this day out. However I’m by no means going to criticize a collection for having too many concepts and never sufficient time to discover all of them in sufficient element.

Oh, and I needed to attract consideration to Unusual New Worlds’ wonderful use of digital levels each right here and for a lot of the season. The world of J’Gal feels fairly plausible, rendered as a dwelling backdrop behind the sphere hospital within the flashback sequences. Given the fee and logistical calls for of attempting to arrange a collection of night time shoots on tough terrain, I can perceive why the group opted to shoot the scene within the studio. However whereas keen-eyed followers might be searching for the perimeters of the stage, the environment feels much more actual than in the event that they have been performing in entrance of a inexperienced display.

It’s clear now that every season of Unusual New Worlds conforms to an identical form throughout its run. After a mission-setting premiere, you get three episodes exploring customary Trek tropes, with a deal with Una and La’an. Episode 5 is a Spock-heavy romantic comedy romp, adopted by a heavy episode that emphasizes the season’s general theme. Seven is a lighter episode, whereas eight is primarily centered on Dr. M’Benga, whereas 9 is one among two massive showcase episodes to cap the season. And I’m hoping I get some credit score for clocking – final 12 months – that we have been going to see a musical episode, which is what we’re getting subsequent week.

Trending Merchandise

Add to compare
Corsair 5000D Airflow Tempered Glass Mid-Tower ATX PC Case – Black

Corsair 5000D Airflow Tempered Glass Mid-Tower ATX PC Case – Black

Add to compare
CORSAIR 7000D AIRFLOW Full-Tower ATX PC Case, Black

CORSAIR 7000D AIRFLOW Full-Tower ATX PC Case, Black


We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Shopping cart